Reading
texts online can definitely be different than reading printed texts, and I
think online reading can be much more efficient than printed reading. However, authors
like Sven Birkerts, an American essayist, does not think that electronic
reading is the way to go. This is because he believes that the media shift from
printed to electronic texts will ultimately cause us to think that images and
impressions are more important than logic and concept. I have a couple thoughts
about this matter. Number one, images can add to the overall meaning of
something you are reading, so they are not a problem. And number two, frankly,
I don’t see how he believes that people will think that images and impressions
are more important than logic and concept. I feel this way because everyone
knows images just support concepts, but the written concept that the images are
supporting is what we are actually getting information from.
Furthermore, Birkerts thinks that
the printed text is what makes people speak more elegantly, and he thinks
people who read electronic texts speak more plainly. The way I see it is words
are words no matter what they are on. Birkerts continues to state his opinion
about everything that is not printed onto paper as he says, ”With visual media,
impression and image take precedence over logic and concept, and detail and
linear sequentiality are sacrificed” (122). The piece of paper that someone
would read words off of is not what is going to make it be more full of detail
or linear sequentiality. No. What is going to make something detailed and
logical is how it is written, not
what it is written on. In fact, I see
electronic texts as a way more efficient way to find details about specific
subjects than printed texts would be.
Electronically, you can type in
your subject and a few keywords about it into a search engine and instantly get
loads of sources with many details on exactly what you are looking for. In a
printed text you have to find the actual part of the text that talks about the
specific subject you are looking for details on. If the text doesn’t have an
index then have fun spending the next few hours just looking for the part that is about your subject. When you find the
section or chapter about your subject, the fun doesn’t end! You get to continue
skimming the pages looking for keywords that could potentially provide you the
details on the subject that you have spent the last several hours looking for. At
the end of the day, you’re going to be wishing you just typed in a few words to
Google.
It's true that electronic texts can give us a more efficient reading process--in some cases, like when we are just looking for a fact. But not all knowledge is derived from facts, some is derived from following a thought-process. I think that's what Birkerts is worried about--that we'll focus on what we can get fast and ignore everything else.
ReplyDeleteI agree, especially the part about the use of images. Just as you did in your blog, I used images to help drive home the point. Media can truly be an amazing thing that can expand your thinking process!
ReplyDelete